Big lithium riches await in Bolivia — the challenge is extracting them
SANTIAGO, Chile — A small army of workers from cities and villages across Bolivia boards the buses for the last leg of a commute that can last days. The meandering, bumpy dirt roads, the thin air at high altitude, the ordeal of bringing labor into the blinding white plain of the worlds largest salt flat — all of this stands between anyone who dreams of retrieving Bolivias lithium riches and turning them into electric-car batteries.
These workers will spend two weeks at the Uyuni salt flat in the southern tip of Bolivia before they return home for a seven-day rest. They are attempting to build a world-class lithium mine on top of the Andes mountains, about 12,000 feet above sea level at the heart of landlocked Bolivia. The nearest port is at least 500 kilometers and a border crossing away.
From above, this vast area appears so white it gets mistaken for a giant snow plain. The salt crystallizes in the dry season, forming millions of tile-looking hexagons that span an area as large as Connecticut. During the wet season, its covered by a thin layer of water that forms a giant mirror, reflecting the sky so neatly that the line of the horizon disappears. The visual effect draws thousands of visitors and the Dakar Rally every year, making it Bolivias top tourist destination.
Getting the lithium out will prove far more difficult than bringing tourists in. Most observers doubt that Bolivias lithium will ever support a commercial mining operation. Still, the government is eager to tap into the global hunger for a mineral essential to power electric cars and build storage batteries. The ambition is to ultimately transform Bolivia into a manufacturer of the rechargeable batteries inside the nearly 300 EV models expected to reach the market by 2022, according to Bloomberg NEF.
"Bolivia will be a relevant actor in the global lithium market within four or five years," said Juan Carlos Montenegro, general manager of state-owned Yacimientos de Litio Bolivianos, or YLB. "And we dont plan on stopping there."
The Bolivian government — South Americas longest-standing populist regime — is vowing to make itself into a mineral-and-battery player using mainly its own engineers. Its pilot plant in Uyuni has produced close to 250 tons of lithium carbonate this year, and YLB said it can bring production to 150,000 tons within five years. This would make Bolivia one of the top-producing nations and the source of about 20 percent of the worlds lithium by 2022, according to Bloomberg NEF projections.
But the country also needs a help from the few foreign companies undaunted by the prospect of retrieving lithium from one of the most remote places on the planet. And there seems to be at least one willing to take that risk.
ACI Systems Alemania GmbH has no prior mining experience.
Based in Zimmern ob Rottweil, a rural village at the heart of Germanys Black Forest, the company is a subsidiary of ACI Group, which provides project-management support to the photovoltaic, battery and automotive industries. ACI Systems Alemania employs just 20 people and was created solely to focus on building a lithium mine in Bolivia. CEO Wolfgang Schmutz is betting that he will succeed in an impoverished nation that has frustrated a long list of elite lithium suitors.
"I know Bolivia. Me and others in the company have personal relationships with the country," Schmutz said in a phone interview. "Whatever we promised we made it happen so far. There is a trust relation that we want to continue building up."
ACI recently signed an agreement with Bolivian President Evo Morales to build a $250 million lithium operation, the first step towards manufacturing cathodes and batteries in Bolivia. The deal is expected to be formalized this month into a 49-51 joint venture with YLB. The German company has not yet secured financing for the project.
"Bolivia doesnt host any established cathode producers," said Andrew Miller, a senior analyst at Benchmark Mineral Intelligence. "There are significant hurdles in them producing lithium, let alone developing a downstream industry for battery cathodes."
The reason to try is clear: Demand for lithium is expected to more than double by 2025. The soft, light mineral is mined mainly in Australia, Chile and Argentina. Bolivia has plenty — 9 million tons that have never been mined commercially, the second-largest amount in the world — but until now theres been no practical way to mine and sell it.
Bringing Bolivias supply to market would help lithium miners who have so far struggled to match global demand. Top producers FMC Corp. and Albemarle Corp. in the U.S., SQM in Chile and Tianqi Lithium Corp. in China are investing billions to expand their existing operations. Even the most experienced are suffering setbacks, with SQM reporting delays and unexpected difficulties in expanding in Chile. Albemarle reported stoppages in its operations in Chile, China and Australia for different reasons during the third quarter.
FMC and South Koreas steelmaker giant POSCO have in the past attempted to ink deals with Morales government that would have set up lithium operations in Uyuni. Those attempts failed, with talks stalling and investors walking out in the face of uncertainty or unreasonable government demands.
Latin Americas poorest nation has had at least 27 different presidents and military juntas rule in the last five decades. President Morales, elected in 2006, is the countrys longest-serving leader and the last of a generation of leftists, including Venezuelas Hugo Chavez, that came to power promising social justice.
Morales nationalized hydrocarbons, Bolivias main source of revenue, as well as the electricity grid and telecoms. He vowed to "industrialize with dignity and sovereignty," promising that raw lithium would not be exploited by foreign corporations but instead processed by state-controlled entities in Bolivia and transformed into batteries. Morales once said he wanted to see "a lithium-powered Toyota made in Bolivia."
"Bolivia is quite frankly very risky relative to other parts of the world for lithium investment," said Chris Berry, an analyst and founder of research firm House Mountain Partners LLC. "Investors are concerned with both return on capital and return of capital."
In South America, lithium is found mixed in a salty mud sitting beneath salt flats high in the mountains. To extract it, miners pump the brine into massive ponds, where it is left to evaporate for months. This concentrated liquid is transformed into industrial chemical plants for processing, where it is tuned into lithium carbonate or lithium hydroxide. Battery giants like Samsung SDI and Panasonic turn these products into the rechargeable batteries that go into electric vehicles.
ACI has no track record dealing with brine or manufacturing battery parts. But it has very optimistic goals in Bolivia.
The German companys agreement with YLB calls for an initial investment of $250 million to build lithium processing plant in Uyuni, with production starting in 2021 and reaching full capacity of up to 40,000 tons of lithium hydroxide per year by the end of 2022. That would be roughly double the capacity that FMC, the worlds fourth-largest producer, has in its operations in Argentina.
To pull off this feat, ACI is going to rely on new, untested technology from another German company, K-UTEC AG Salt Technologies, that it believes will speed up the process by producing lithium hydroxide directly from brine. Brine found in Uyuni has high levels of magnesium, which make its lithium less pure and more expensive to produce than that of neighboring salt flats in Chile and Argentina.
"There are too many loose ends and a lot of secrecy on the governments side," said Juan Carlos Zuleta, a Bolivian professor and lithium analyst. "ACI Systems doesnt have the technical nor the financial capacity to undertake a challenge of this magnitude."
In the next few weeks, YLB will also start building a $96 million industrial plant with capacity to produce up to 18,000 tons of lithium carbonate by early 2020, Montenegro said. He said the state-owned company has already seen interest from companies, mainly serving the Chinese battery market, to sign multiyear supply contracts once the plant starts operating.
But mining lithium from brine is not easy, and neither is manufacturing a product with the chemistry composition that battery makers demand at a competitive cost. With the worlds top manufacturers already ramping up production, Bolivia and ACIs push to produce lithium might have started too late.
"Producing lithium to a certain level of purity for cathode production can take a great deal of time," Berry said. "For this project to get to where other players are globally, its going to take years."
Previous attempts to exploit Bolivias lithium resources with companies including Mitsubishi Corp. and Sumitomo Corp. "have so far failed to materialize," HSBC Holdings Plc said in a report emailed Monday. "However, the rise in lithium demand, long-term supply contracts, confidence in government policy and attractive prices could now motivate investment in lithium projects."
Lithium prices reached historic levels earlier this year, with lithium carbonate from South America selling at an average of $15,700 per ton in May and June before prices fell to around $14,375 per ton in October, according to Benchmark Mineral Intelligence. Berry expects lithium prices to plateau at around $12,000 per ton, at which nearly a third of the projects currently in the pipeline would fall off the cost curve. Bolivias big gamble would be marginal at best.
Market dynamics might not matter as much to the Bolivian government, which sees lithium industrialization as the next step after the nationalization of mining and hydrocarbons. "I am certain that lithium will be like an insurance on the economic and political side to contribute to the free and sovereign development of our beloved Bolivia," Morales said in August.
The country is holding presidential elections next year, and Morales government is expected to make an effort to close the lithium deal beforehand, following a significant blow at the International Court of Justice on a case related to Bolivias dispute for sea access to Chile.
"In Bolivia we have a government thats just been selling illusions, telling fairy tales and now theyre in a rush to show that they did a very good job and that lithium advances at a steady pace," Zuleta said. "Theyre not interested in whether the country wins or loses — theyre interested in remaining in power."